Fatty Arbuckle Proposes Marriage

Roscoe Arbuckle blah blah
Roscoe Arbuckle prepares to ask Mary Thurman to marry him.

In 1920, comedian Roscoe “Fatty” Arbuckle made a movie that was banned in the United States, and wasn’t shown to an American audience until 1981.

It wasn’t the subject matter of the movie that brought about the ban. It was Arbuckle’s unfortunate circumstance; he was arrested for murder shortly after filming wrapped. Because of the arrest, all of Arbuckle’s films were banned by the Motion Picture Producers and Distributors of America (MPPDA).

The case went to trial three times without a conviction. Arbuckle himself was spared, but his career was not. The MPPDA ban and unfavourable popular opinion meant he was never able to star in a film again.

(We’re not covering the details of the murder, and all that went with it, but you can read more about it here. It is juicy stuff.)

This last movie Arbuckle starred in was Leap Year, a farce about a well-meaning and wealthy young man who keeps giving women the impression he wants to marry them.

We can guess what you’re thinking: Arbuckle does not have the traditional leading-man looks or physique. But as you watch the film, you see he is funny and charming, and you can understand why so many women fall for him.

The one woman, though, who has stolen Arbuckle’s heart is Mary Thurman, a nurse who cared for Arbuckle’s ailing uncle and was fired by said uncle because he didn’t like her haircut.

Arbuckle truly is the star here, and he makes acting look effortless. He is surprisingly agile and appears to be very strong. In one scene, he is golfing – with a club that resembles a hockey stick – and, when he is finished, he shoves his giant clubs and his junior caddy in his golf bag, and carries them with one hand as he strides off the course.

Everything about Leap Year is cheeky. The title cards include playful commentary and very witty lines. There are, of course, lots of great sight gags. For example, several of Arbuckle’s would-be fiancés move into his large house, each unaware of the others’ presence; these poor women keep entering rooms just as another is exiting. This is a premise we have seen many times in movies, but it would still be fresh material in the early 1920s.

Leap Year is so much fun, you’ll forget that you’re watching a silent picture. It pokes fun at infatuation, misplaced loyalties and the way many of us behave in a relationship.

It’s a film that everyone can enjoy after an unnecessary 60-year absence.

Leap Year: starring Roscoe “Fatty” Arbuckle, Mary Thurman. Directed by James Cruze. Written by Walter Woods (adaptation) and Sarah Y. Mason (story). Paramount Pictures, 1921, B&W, 60 mins.



  1. Hmmmmm, what a fascinating story about Arbuckle and his troubles. I know absolutely nothing about him or his movies, which is such a shame, but I’m looking forward to reading more! Leap Year is one movie I’d love to see, cheeky or not 🙂 For some reason, I’m drawn to the silents lately. I blame Will 🙂


  2. I am so excited about about “Leap Year”! I have always enjoyed the Arbuckle films that I have seen, but don’t often know which ones to see. I bought a collection of his films and am thrilled to discover that “Leap Year” is in the set. I most assuredly will be watching this one soon. Thanks for the inspiration.


    • Isn’t it a shame it took so long for it to be shown to American audiences? When you consider some of the poorly-made movies that are shown in theatres and then regularly on television, it’s a shame that this funny little satire was out of circulation for decades.


  3. Thanks for the love for Mr. Arbuckle! He still needs the help.

    I was walking through the room when I heard someone on NCIS say “I thought she was 18!” and the other character respond “That’s what Fatty Arbuckle said.”

    Sigh. And people wonder why I don’t watch TV.

    Keep up the great work!


    • Arbuckle may not have been a saint, but I don’t think he was guilty of the incident for which he was tried. It is a real shame that he is more remembered for that, than for his considerable talent.


  4. Ruth, I’d heard about how Arbuckle’s name had been so unfairly dragged through the mud. It’s frustrating that after all these years, there are still so many people who don’t know the real facts of the case. I’m glad you wrote about LEAP YEAR to help set the record straight – besides, it sounds hilarious! BRAVA to you for helping Our Man Roscoe get his good name back, even after all these years!


  5. I’ve only seen one or two Fatty Arbuckle films (in a film class long ago), so I wasn’t familiar with LEAP YEAR. That made your post all the more fascinating. I remember first reading about his legal problems in the Kenneth Anger’s notorious book HOLLYWOOD BABYLON.


Start Singin', Mac!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.