Why Tom Neal Can’t Call Police

Tom Neal (right) pleads with Ann Savage to be reasonable.
Tom Neal (right) pleads with Ann Savage to be reasonable. (Image: Claqueta)

They say there’s one question a film noir has to answer right away, and that is: Why don’t they call the police?

That would be the normal thing to do if, for instance, you stumbled upon a victim of a violent crime. However, if movie characters went to the police each time someone was murdered/robbed/blackmailed, we wouldn’t have a very interesting selection of crime dramas, would we?

Here’s where film noir makes things interesting. In film noir, people can’t go to the police. The only way to solve their dilemma is to face it themselves – as grim a task as that is. A film noir world is a place where you don’t know who to trust, and people aren’t always what they seem.

This is the case in Detour (1946), a paranoid, nothing-goes-right film about a man (Tom Neal) who wants only one thing – to travel from New York to Los Angeles to marry his fiancé. As is the case with many good noirs, the film is told in flashbacks and we are gradually led to discover a gritty and desperate situation.

As he starts to hitchhike across the country, Neal is picked up by an amiable “travelling salesman” (Edmund MacDonald). After driving for the better part of a day, MacDonald asks Neal to take the driver’s seat while he sleeps.

Aww – ain’t this sweet? Neal drives and MacDonald has a lovely little nap, resting comfortably against the passenger door. Just two buddies travelling down the open road.

One key characteristic of film noir is the plot twist, and Detour has plenty of those. The first occurs when Neal stops the car and opens the door against which the sleeping MacDonald is slumped. MacDonald spills onto the ground, slams his head on a rock and dies instantly.

Well! If that weren’t awkward enough, it turns out MacDonald was a rather unsavoury character who has a lot of cash in his wallet, and we mean a LOT of cash.

Neal is in a quandary but, in true noir fashion, he does not wait for police. How come? First, he’s on a highway in the middle of nowhere. Second, he’s convinced police wouldn’t believe him – and he’s probably right. Here’s a hitchhiker, alone with a dead man and a wallet stuffed with cash on a deserted highway. Nah, nothing suspicious here.

Here’s a second plot twist: Neal decides to take the car (and the dead man’s wallet) and continue on to L.A. Along the way, he picks up a hitchhiker (Ann Savage), an abrupt woman who doesn’t like questions until, suddenly, she asks one of her own: “Where did you leave his body?”

Yikes! How on earth does she know?

By now, we are completely immersed in the world of film noir. Neal can’t go to the police because Savage has made it clear she will testify against him. He also can’t escape Savage’s clutches because, like every good femme fatale, she has a very controlling personality. He is alone must solve his predicament, if he can.

It’s obvious that Detour was filmed on a budget, as some of the most notable noirs are, but it doesn’t interfere with a gripping story. The camera work is top-notch and the performances by Neal and Savage are outstanding. The script, too, is water-tight and it delivers a gasp-out-loud twist near the end of the movie that you will not believe.

You may or may not agree with the film’s overall philosophy, which is summed up in a single statement just before the closing credits. But you won’t forget Tom Neal’s desperation in a film noir world or his inability to summon police when he needed them most.

Detour: Starring Tom Neal, Ann Savage, Claudia Drake. Directed by Edgar G. Ulmer. Written by Martin Goldsmith. Producers Releasing Corp., B&W, 1946, 67 mins.



  1. Oh R.A., I am so in love with the way you write….the way you tell the stories of these movies. My heart literally starts to race a little! Crazy, I know, but true. I have Detour on the DVR, but I’ve yet to watch it. I must watch soon. What is it with me and Noirs lately anyway? Love them!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Ruth, as you may have already figured out by now, I’m a sucker for a great film noir! 🙂 DETOUR is one of those films I’ve seen bits and pieces of, and this one sounds downright nightmarish — and I mean that as a compliment in DETOUR’s surreal noir world! I always enjoy the way you weave the story of the protagonist’s predicament, pulling us into the story in a witty, lively package. I’ll have to give DETOUR my undivided attention next time I come across it from start to finish. BRAVA, my friend! 😀


    • Dor, this is one that deserves a person’s undivided attention. The script really pulls you in and gives you a sense of panic and desperation.

      Thanks for your kind comments and your support. 🙂


  3. I just love movies with plot twists and turns. You had me on the edge of my couch when I was reading your description. I’m putting it on my list of movies to watch. Thanks for the recommendation!


  4. This is one of those cult classics that lives up to its reputation (the scene with the telephone cord is a stunner!). You’re right, in film noir, you can’t go to the cops–no matter how bad the situation!


    • Thanks for stopping by! “Detour” is not a well-known film. In fact, I hadn’t heard of it until a couple of months ago, and I BLOG about classic movies! If you have a chance, you should check it out.


  5. I have never heard of this film! And I’m not familiar with any of the stars in it. But I love film noir, and this sounds like a great one. I am going to be on the lookout for this. Thanks for brining it to my attention.


Start Singin', Mac!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.